10-second review: When it comes to discussing grammar, it is important that the term “grammar” be defined. The author of this article defines grammar—and composition—as punctuation, capitalization. usage and spelling. He does not mention syntax.
Source: “Total English Equals Writing Competence.” Thomas H Whalen. Research in the Teaching of English (Spring 1969), 52-61. A publication of the National Council of Teachers of English (NCTE).
Summary: The author defined composition and grammar in the same way and did some research that proved that composition and grammar were related.
Comment: I think that this article was a put-on, a humorous response to the belief that the study of grammar in no way improves writing. However the author had one valid point—the need to define the terms “composition” and “grammar.” I think I will be surprised, maybe astonished, by the different definitions of these terms by different people. RayS.
No comments:
Post a Comment